Circular Business Models

Revision Notes – Circular Business Models

Circular Business Models as Decision-Making Tools
Circular business models (CBMs) are strategic frameworks businesses use to minimise environmental impact while maintaining economic performance. They operate on the principle of keeping resources in circulation for as long as possible, unlike traditional linear models that focus solely on producing, selling and disposing. CBMs influence decisions related to sourcing, production, distribution and product design. They encourage businesses to think about environmental costs, waste prevention and long-term sustainability during every stage of the business cycle. This shift allows companies to reduce reliance on finite resources and align with consumer expectations for responsible and eco-friendly business behaviour.

Traditional Linear Business Models
Traditional business models follow the take–make–waste pathway. Raw materials are extracted, converted into products and eventually discarded after use. This approach prioritises efficiency and profitability but ignores the environmental and social consequences of resource depletion, pollution and waste accumulation. As the global population grows and consumption increases, this model becomes less viable. The costs of environmental damage, declining natural resources and waste management pressures highlight the need for an alternative approach. This is where circular business models provide a more sustainable and regenerative solution for long-term business success.

Definition and Principles of Circular Business Models
Circular business models aim to design waste out of the system. They rely on the principles of reducing resource use, reusing existing materials, repairing and maintaining products, and recycling materials back into new production. These principles ensure that products, components and materials retain their value for as long as possible. CBMs are increasingly being adopted due to global commitments to climate change, resource scarcity concerns and growing stakeholder pressure for businesses to operate responsibly. They also enable innovation in product design, supply chains and customer relationships.

Types of Circular Business Models

1. Circular Supply Models
Circular supply models focus on sourcing renewable, recycled or biodegradable materials to replace finite raw materials. These models encourage companies to shift away from resource-heavy and environmentally damaging production inputs. For instance, a business might replace petroleum-based plastics with plant-based biodegradable alternatives.

The long-term advantage lies in reducing dependency on scarce natural resources, which are becoming more expensive as supplies diminish. Circular supply models promote supply chain resilience and reduce exposure to volatile commodity prices. They also encourage suppliers to innovate, fostering new markets for renewable materials and environmentally responsible production methods. Adopting such models contributes to a more stable and sustainable production system across industries.

2. Resource Recovery Models
Resource recovery models transform waste into valuable resources by capturing materials that would otherwise be thrown away and reprocessing them for reuse. Rather than disposing of used products, waste becomes a new input for fresh production cycles. This reduces pressure on natural resources and minimises the environmental impact associated with landfill, pollution and extraction.

There are several approaches within this model.
Cradle-to-cradle (C2C) design ensures that products are created with their end-of-life stage in mind. Materials are chosen so that they can be reused, safely returned to the environment or recovered for future production. This imitates natural systems where nothing goes to waste.

Closed-loop recycling involves collecting, breaking down and re-manufacturing waste into new products. This eliminates linear disposal systems and supports continuous material circulation. It is commonly seen in industries such as metals, plastics, textiles and electronics.

Industrial symbiosis occurs when one company’s waste or by-product becomes another company’s raw material. This promotes collaboration across industries, reduces waste management costs and opens opportunities for innovation. Combined, these methods make resource recovery models highly effective in reducing environmental burdens and supporting circular economies.

3. Product Life Extension Models
Product life extension models focus on designing and managing products to last longer. This includes maintenance, repairs, upgrades, refurbishment and remanufacturing. Instead of encouraging customers to frequently replace products, businesses ensure that their items can be used over a longer period.

By extending product lifecycles, companies reduce the demand for raw materials needed for new production. This decreases waste generation and lowers environmental impact. Businesses also benefit financially by offering new services such as repair programs, aftercare packages or premium durable products.

Product life extension models allow companies to differentiate themselves from competitors, especially those relying on disposable or low-cost production. Extended durability can become a unique selling point, allowing firms to charge premium prices. In addition, high-quality, long-lasting products promote customer loyalty and strengthen brand reputation. These models are particularly relevant in electronics, appliances, furniture, automobiles and industrial equipment.

4. Sharing Models
Sharing models allow multiple users to access the same product, increasing utilisation rates and reducing the overall demand for product production. Instead of individual ownership, customers share, rent or borrow products. Examples include bicycle sharing systems, car-sharing services, equipment rentals and digital platforms that facilitate peer-to-peer sharing.

These models work well for products that are typically under-used when individually owned. For example, cars remain unused most of the day, and power tools are used only a few times per year by typical households. Sharing models reduce the need for excessive production and minimise waste, thereby reducing resource extraction and environmental damage.

Businesses operating under sharing models can build strong community networks, create new revenue channels and improve customer accessibility to products. They also encourage behavioural change, pushing consumers toward more sustainable consumption patterns. As technology advances, digital platforms make sharing easier and more efficient, increasing adoption rates worldwide.

5. Product Service System Models (PSS)
Product service system models provide the function or service of a product instead of selling the product itself. Customers pay for access or performance rather than ownership. Examples include leasing, subscription services and pay-per-use arrangements. For instance, companies may lease machinery or equipment to businesses, or consumers may subscribe to a service that provides ongoing product upgrades.

This model incentivises businesses to design products that are durable, easy to maintain and energy-efficient, since the company retains responsibility for repairs and replacement. Because businesses remain the product owners, they are motivated to maximise lifespan, recover materials at end-of-life and minimise waste throughout the process.

Product service systems reduce upfront customer costs and provide flexibility and convenience. Companies benefit through long-term customer relationships, predictable revenue streams and reduced environmental impact. PSS models are common in industries such as electronics, transportation, office equipment, technology services and industrial machinery.

Evaluation of Circular Business Models

Benefits of Circular Business Models
Circular business models significantly reduce environmental footprints by minimising waste, decreasing carbon emissions and lowering the extraction of natural resources. They contribute to long-term business sustainability and resilience by creating closed systems where resources are continuously reused.

Companies adopting CBMs enhance their corporate image, especially as consumers increasingly prefer environmentally responsible brands. These models help attract and retain skilled employees who value organisations with strong corporate social responsibility practices. Businesses can gain competitive advantages through innovation, new revenue streams, improved efficiency and increased customer loyalty.

Furthermore, circular models open opportunities for cost savings in the long run, especially when waste reduction, resource efficiency and material recovery processes become streamlined. They enable companies to align with regulatory pressures, global sustainability targets and industry standards that are gradually moving toward circular economic principles.

Limitations of Circular Business Models
Despite their advantages, circular business models come with challenges. Transitioning to a circular system can be expensive in the short term, requiring investment in new technologies, redesigned supply chains and improved product designs. This shift also demands training, stakeholder buy-in and sometimes a complete restructuring of traditional business processes.

Another limitation is consumer behaviour. Not all customers are willing to pay higher prices for sustainable, durable or shared products. Some consumers prefer to own items rather than rent or share them. Others may be hesitant about refurbished or repaired goods due to assumptions about quality and performance.

Circular business models may reduce economies of scale because they often focus on more durable products or smaller production runs. In some sectors, implementing CBMs is difficult without government incentives, regulations or infrastructure, such as recycling systems, repair networks or renewable material markets.

Overall, while circular business models offer strong long-term benefits, businesses need strategic planning, investment and customer engagement to successfully implement them.

​